Welcome to Richardsons Cycle Club

RCC Login

Welcome to Richardsons Cycle Club Website.
Please login with your username and password. If you do not have an account, please register using the Sign-Up form to the right. Site Membership will provide you with full forum access and benefits such as personal profiles and private messaging.

Email Us

If you have any questions or queries please contact us here »

Member Login

Lost your password?

Not a member yet? Sign Up!

Math Required!
What is the sum of: 12 + 5    

feedback
You must be logged in to post Login Register

Search Forums:


 




Double or Triple?

UserPost

1:29 pm
September 12, 2009


Matt Schofield

RCC Junkie

posts 78

1

Which is better?

1:59 pm
September 12, 2009


mike scott

I love RCC!

scarborough

posts 286

2

Everyone is different but I am on a double it depends on your plans, Lewis rides on a double.

I gave the triple away.

I think if you time trialing and road racing a double is fine.

4:20 pm
September 12, 2009


Dan Joyce

Moderator

posts 596

3

Racing double (e.g. 42/52) is fine for racing ONLY. For a bike that will be ridden recreationally as well, it's nice to have some lower gears. You can do that with a triple (e.g. 30/40/50) or a compact double (e.g. 34/50). It depends what cassette you've got at the back too. There's a big difference between a 12-21 and a 12-27. 

(These numbers, by the way, are just the numbers of teeth on the chainring or sprocket.)

I like compact doubles, although my training/winter bike (which Matthew raced at Burton Fleming) has a triple simply because it came with one. I raced on it a few times like that last year. A triple set up is a little heavier but it's not a huge deal at our level of racing. 

So if your bike will be for racing only, a racing double is fine. If you'll also want to do other rides on it, I'd recommend a compact double or maybe a triple, with the compact double getting the nod if that's a same-cost option. 

4:24 pm
September 12, 2009


Mark G

Moderator

posts 1106

4

Triple are ok but a compact double chainset would suffice and gve you the same spread of gears and are lighter. I would recommend a compact for you Matt as you do not want to be pushing huge gears at the moment. 


If you are looking at double then it depends on the amount of teeth…standard used to be 53/39/ but compact are very popular now which have 50/34.


5:44 pm
September 12, 2009


Tommo

I love RCC!

I Love SPCC more

posts 258

5

FSA do 52/38 semi-compact's as well, could be best of all worlds, matched up with a 12-27 cassette. Wink

5m 10:15 - 10m 19:28 - 15m 31:06 - 25m 52:58 - 30m 1:05:34 - 50m 1:47:36 - 100m 3:47:15 - 12Hr 274.69m

4:43 am
September 14, 2009


Dan Joyce

Moderator

posts 596

6

I agree with Mark. Pushing big gears isn't good for you when your bones are still growing. So:

compact double > triple > racing double

in that order.

The triple would give lower gears than the compact (the smallest chainring is smaller than a compact's by the same sort of margin that a compact is smaller than a racing double - e.g. 4-teeth smaller, versus 5-8T smaller). But with something like a 12-25, 12-26 or 12-27 cassette, the compact will still be okay for riding up big hills.

1:01 pm
September 14, 2009


Matt Schofield

RCC Junkie

posts 78

7

I think I'm going to get this Specialized Allez from Richardsons, I went in today to have a look at what they've got in


http://www.evanscycles.com/pro…..e-ec019545

1:22 pm
September 14, 2009


Toms

I love RCC!

posts 276

8

i think rex has one of them? nice bikes!

dalby red route - 1:41:11

1:40 pm
September 14, 2009


Matt Schofield

RCC Junkie

posts 78

9

He's got the Specialized allez Sport, I think it's the upgrade

2:36 pm
September 14, 2009


Tommo

I love RCC!

I Love SPCC more

posts 258

10

Hey Matt, this bike has much better spec +18 gears and has a compact chainset as well, the one you're highlighted has a full size road chainset and only 16 'cheap rubbish' gears that won't last a year.

http://www.bikescene.co.uk/mor…..amp;sale=0


Just past Whitby at Guisborough.Wink

5m 10:15 - 10m 19:28 - 15m 31:06 - 25m 52:58 - 30m 1:05:34 - 50m 1:47:36 - 100m 3:47:15 - 12Hr 274.69m

2:55 pm
September 14, 2009


Mark G

Moderator

posts 1106

11

Matt…..I am sure Debbie can do you a good deal on a Specialized including the Allez 18.  However a lot of stock is sold out this time of year so Bike Scene may have one of the very few still left or may not (some have it on their site but dont have the stock).  


You could consider waiting until the new 2010 models come out and see what is available and at what price but they could be more expensive.  

3:12 pm
September 14, 2009


Matt Schofield

RCC Junkie

posts 78

12

That bike that Tom found is the same as my Dad's (apart from his is a Triple) and i don't think we should have the same bike because my Mum says we'll look like geeks lol

so is that Specialized Allez in Richardsons not right for me then?

4:13 pm
September 14, 2009


Dan Joyce

Moderator

posts 596

13

The 2010 Specialized Allez isn't 'wrong' (Specialized Allez bikes have always been good bikes). However, the 2009 version is better. Bike prices have risen steeply recently and the only way to keep them down is to make the components not quite as good. So the bikes that have kept their prices similar (or that have increased in price less) do tend to have been 'down spec'd' a bit.

That said, there's nothing wrong with 8-speed. The chains usually wear more slowly than 9 or 10 speed and they don't snap as often, because they're thicker. The Shimano 2300 groupset is fine too. It certainly isn't 'rubbish' and I'll bet £10 that it will last more than a year. My training bike has 8-speed. I used to run 8-speed on my mountain bike too.

The main practical issue with the 2010 Allez is that it has a racing double. That means no bailout gears. The Allez 24 is £30 more expensive but does come with a triple chainset. Roadies can be a bit sniffy about these - as Tommo is about 8-speed! - but they work fine and the weight penalty is fairly trivial. The 2010 Giant Defy 3.5 is much the same as the 2010 Specialized Allez. 

Before getting the 2010 Allez, if you're set on it, I would go out on your Dad's bike and ride it up the biggest hill you can find WITHOUT using the small chainring. Keep it in the middle ring at the front and use the rear gears as normal. If you're happy with that, you'll be okay on the racing double that the 16-speed Allez has.

Having said all that: if you can find the 09 version, it is better. 

5:29 pm
September 14, 2009


Tommo

I love RCC!

I Love SPCC more

posts 258

14

Bikescence is a live web-site so they 'will' have 2009's in all sizes, they are only just out of date thats why this is the case.

I just thought I'd try and help out with a different option that does have what the kid wants - Compact Cranks.

I not sniffy about 8-Speed at all or Triples, it's just better spec all round for a small amount extra.

I ran a Triple from 2004 to 2006, this was when I was just starting like the lad, and I would high recommend a triple to anyone starting out, until you stop using the granny ring then you can get rid. (mechs look crap though - too long)

Not sure about 2300 though, I've had cheap Shimano before in the past - waste of time, even when well oiled.

5m 10:15 - 10m 19:28 - 15m 31:06 - 25m 52:58 - 30m 1:05:34 - 50m 1:47:36 - 100m 3:47:15 - 12Hr 274.69m

5:31 pm
September 14, 2009


Tommo

I love RCC!

I Love SPCC more

posts 258

15

Forgot to say - No deals on Specialized anywhere - they are a cartel and won't allow it or dealers get kicked out. Confused

Only 'out of date' models can get discounted. Wink

5m 10:15 - 10m 19:28 - 15m 31:06 - 25m 52:58 - 30m 1:05:34 - 50m 1:47:36 - 100m 3:47:15 - 12Hr 274.69m

11:57 am
September 15, 2009


mike scott

I love RCC!

scarborough

posts 286

16

Yes but if your buying a brand new bike you dont want 8 speed as you wont be happy when most people have 9, 10, and even 11

2:37 pm
September 15, 2009


Tommo

I love RCC!

I Love SPCC more

posts 258

17

2010 Specialized Allez Sport 18 -18 gears same as 2009 model (sora) compact cranks - not the same colour as your Dads Smile

Bad news is the price - £599 it is then. Cry There's always sumat. Confused

This time of year is when shops are getting rid of 'old out-dated' bikes i.e. 2009 models and 2010 models start coming out, so look on the web for good deals with better spec for the same money. Next year a 2010 will be out of date in September, take time to make the right choice 'cos you'll have to live with that choice - don't just buy cos you've seen one in a shop window.

5m 10:15 - 10m 19:28 - 15m 31:06 - 25m 52:58 - 30m 1:05:34 - 50m 1:47:36 - 100m 3:47:15 - 12Hr 274.69m

4:50 pm
September 15, 2009


Dan Joyce

Moderator

posts 596

18

mike scott said:

Yes but if your buying a brand new bike you dont want 8 speed as you wont be happy when most people have 9, 10, and even 11


Like I say, some people are sniffy about 8-speed. Wink

I prefer it to 10- or 11-speed, personally. It's only a shame that you now have to put up with an entry-level groupset to get it. 

Well, kinda. If I were building up a road bike from parts, I'd use 10-speed Campag levers (probably Centaur), a short cage Shimano 9-speed rear derailleur (probably Tiagra), an 8-speed chain (e.g. Sram PC48), and an 8-speed Shimano cassette. That would give:

- 8 gears at the back end (with two redundant clicks at the lever). That's plenty.

- better cable routing than Shimano at the bars

- perfect shifts (you can't mix anything, but this works - and the Campag front shifter is better for trimming the front mech too)

- a chain and cassette that would last longer than your fancy shamncy 10 or 11-speed groupsets and be cheap to replace when they did die.

You can also mix 11-speed Campag levers with Shimano 9-speed cassettes and mechs. 

That doesn't help, Matt, though. So ultimately I'd agree with Tommo in this case and say that (if you want to stick with Specialized) the £599 to get the Allez Sport 18 is worth the bump.

On the other hand, if £500 is your absolute limit, you could also consider a Giant Defy 4 (8-speed rear end, triple chainset). At £475ish, you could put the spare £25 towards better tyres (e.g. Michelin Pro 3 Race). That will have a bigger effect on your speed than how long your rear mech is, or whether you've got 8 or 9 (or 10 or 11!) sprockets. As a bonus, it will take full length mudguards, so if you get a better bike in a few years' time, you could make that your training bike. 


5:12 pm
September 15, 2009


Mark G

Moderator

posts 1106

19

I feel sorry for Matt…he thought he would ask a simple question and for some basic guidance! Smile


His head must be spinning now!


1:33 pm
September 16, 2009


Tommo

I love RCC!

I Love SPCC more

posts 258

20

He's getting 'top guidance' LaughLaugh

Easy to say 'yeah buy that one it's OK' but that's the wrong answer.

5m 10:15 - 10m 19:28 - 15m 31:06 - 25m 52:58 - 30m 1:05:34 - 50m 1:47:36 - 100m 3:47:15 - 12Hr 274.69m

3:42 pm
September 16, 2009


Toms

I love RCC!

posts 276

21

matt, find the bike you like, and try to test it, see how you get on with it, a well fitted bike will make more of a difference than a double or a triple, i can almost guarentee you wont notice the difference in weight.

dalby red route - 1:41:11

12:57 pm
September 18, 2009


Matt Schofield

RCC Junkie

posts 78

22

Thanks for all the help every1! Smile


I bought the 2010 Specialized Allez 24 2day from richardsons


http://www.evanscycles.com/pro…..e-ec019546


About the Richardsons Cycle Club forum

Most Users Ever Online:

53


Currently Online:

Heapo

10 Guests

Forum Stats:

Groups: 4

Forums: 13

Topics: 959

Posts: 4868

Membership:

There are 2816 Members

There have been 28 Guests

There is 1 Admin

There are 4 Moderators

Top Posters:

deb - 582

matthew - 309

mike scott - 286

Toms - 276

Tommo - 258

king of the hill - 156

Administrators: admin (51 Posts)

Moderators: Dan Joyce (596 Posts), kat (2 Posts), KeithU (63 Posts), Mark G (1106 Posts)




RCC Ad Icon

Richardsons Cycle Club is a Cycling and Mountain Bike Club located in Scarborough, North Yorkshire.

Formed in 2009, RCC welcomes members interested in Road and Mountain Biking. If you are interested in joining RCC please contact:

Lorraine Naylor: richardsonscc@googlemail.com
Richardsons Cycles Shop: 01723 352682

Copyright © 2009 Richardsons Cycle Club. All rights reserved.

Richardsons Cycles Shop

38-40 Castle Road
Scarborough
North Yorkshrie
YO11 1XE